False Promise of Marriage: Supreme Court Quashes the Rana Rape Case
In Shiv Pratap Singh Rana v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr. (Criminal Appeal No. 1552 of 2023), the Supreme Court quashed a case under Sections 376 and 506 IPC. The relationship appeared consensual and had soured, the FIR came two years late, and no supporting material was seized. This page sets out the facts, the law, the arguments and the ruling, and what changed under the BNS.
Shiv Pratap Singh Rana v. State of Madhya Pradesh: why a promise to marry did not make out rape
A woman lodged an FIR in September 2018 at Vishwavidhyalaya Police Station, Gwalior. She alleged that in 2016 the appellant threatened to upload her photographs unless she came with him to Gwalior, and that he then committed rape. She also said he promised marriage, later demanded dowry, and took money and jewellery. The Sessions Judge framed charges under Sections 376(2)(n) and 506 IPC. The High Court refused to interfere in revision, and the Supreme Court granted leave and stayed the trial.
The Court examined whether the material, taken as it stood, could support a conviction. It looked at consent under Sections 375 and 90 IPC and at the tests for a false promise of marriage in Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 9 SCC 608. It also weighed the two-year delay in the FIR, the voluntary movements of the complainant, and the absence of any seized photographs, phone or jewellery. It held that forcing the appellant to face trial would be an abuse of process. Read the original order on the Supreme Court of India website before relying on this summary.
Broken promise or false promise?
The Supreme Court drew a line between a promise that was never meant and a promise that was meant but not kept.
Short explainers from Adv. Sudip Patra
More short explainers on our YouTube channel: Patra’s Law Chambers on YouTube ↗
A rape case based on a promise to marry has been filed. Which stage are you at?
This is general information, not legal advice. The forum and remedy depend on how far the case has moved, so check your papers with a lawyer before acting.
Choose one of the options above.
How a case like this moves through the courts
This is the usual route of a criminal complaint alleging rape on a false promise of marriage. Timings vary from court to court.
The police register the FIR and record the complainant’s statement (Section 180 BNSS, earlier Section 161 CrPC). The accused can consider anticipatory bail at this stage.
The complainant’s statement may be recorded before a Magistrate (Section 183 BNSS, earlier Section 164 CrPC). Courts later compare it with the police statement for contradictions.
The police file a chargesheet and the case is committed to the Sessions Court, as the offence is triable there. The accused sees the materials the prosecution relies on.
The judge takes a prima facie view of the materials and either discharges the accused or frames a charge. In the Rana case the discharge application was rejected and charges were framed.
The accused can challenge the order in revision or seek quashing. Read more on quashing of criminal cases in the Calcutta High Court.
An appeal by special leave can be filed. Here the Supreme Court quashed the charge-framing order and the High Court’s order, ending the proceedings. For a Supreme Court matter, see the Supreme Court advocate consultation page.
Three ideas that decide these cases – tap a card
Consent means voluntary participation after exercising intelligence and choice. Consent given under fear or a misconception of fact is not valid consent (Section 90 IPC, now Section 28 BNS).
The promise must have been false from the start, made in bad faith, and must have directly affected the woman’s decision. A relationship that later turns sour is a different matter.
The Court noted a two-year delay in lodging the FIR, nothing seized by the police, and contradictions in the statements. Together these made conviction very unlikely.
What the Supreme Court looked at
Consent and misconception of fact
Consent must come from voluntary participation after using intelligence and choice. Consent given under fear or a misconception of fact is not valid consent. The Court asked whether such a defect was shown on the material available, relying on Dr. Dhruvaram Murlidhar Sonar v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 18 SCC 191.
When a promise to marry is false
The promise must have been false and given in bad faith from the start. It must also have been of immediate relevance to the woman’s decision to engage in the sexual act. A relationship that later breaks down is not, by itself, proof of a false promise.
Discharge, charge and revision
At the stage of charge the court takes a prima facie view of the material. Here the Supreme Court held that the material could not lead to a conviction, so sending the case to trial would be an abuse of the court process.
Delayed FIR and missing corroboration
The FIR came two years after the alleged events. No photographs, phone or jewellery were seized, and the statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC had contradictions. The Court treated these as weaknesses that mattered.
Section 376 IPC is now Section 69 BNS (sexual intercourse by deceitful means)
- Section 69 BNS covers sexual intercourse by deceitful means, including a false promise to marry made with no intention of keeping it.
- Punishment under Section 69 BNS is imprisonment of up to 10 years and fine. Verify the current text on India Code before relying on it.
- Rape itself now sits in Sections 63 to 64 BNS, and criminal intimidation (Section 506 IPC) in Section 351 BNS. Verify the exact sub-sections for your facts.
- Conduct before 1 July 2024 is still tried under the IPC; the BNS applies to later offences.
- The Rana principles on consent, delay and corroboration remain useful when courts consider such cases. See IPC to BNS for the full section table.
Supreme Court rulings on a false promise of marriage
Shiv Pratap Singh Rana follows a settled line of Supreme Court decisions. These cases separate a promise that was false from the start from a relationship that later broke down.
2024
Soured consensual relationship is not rape
The FIR came two years after the events. Nothing the complainant mentioned (photographs, phone, jewellery) was seized, her statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC did not match, and she had travelled with the accused of her own will. The Supreme Court held that no case of rape or criminal intimidation was made out, set aside the charge order and quashed the proceedings as an abuse of process.
2019
Two conditions for vitiated consent
A promise to marry makes consent a misconception of fact only if two things are shown. First, the promise was false: made in bad faith, with no intention of keeping it when it was given. Second, the false promise directly shaped the woman’s decision to have the sexual relationship. A promise that is simply broken later does not meet this test.
2013
Breach of promise differs from false promise
The Court held that failing to keep a promise to marry is not, by itself, a false promise. The court has to be satisfied that the accused never meant to marry from the very beginning and made the promise only to get consent. Here the conviction was set aside because the adult complainant had gone with the accused of her own will.
2018
Consent must be judged from all circumstances
Consent means taking part voluntarily, after using one’s own intelligence and making a choice. Section 90 IPC removes consent only where it was given under fear or a misconception of fact. Where the woman freely chose the relationship out of love, and not because of a deceitful promise, a rape charge cannot stand, and the proceedings may be quashed.
2023
Not every broken promise is false
The Supreme Court said it would be a folly to treat every breach of a promise to marry as a false promise and to prosecute it under Section 376 IPC. The prosecution must show that the accused had no intention of marrying from the start. A ten-year sentence was set aside and the accused was acquitted.
2024
Long relationship without protest suggests consent
A physical relationship that went on for years without protest or insistence on marriage points to consent, not deception. The Court warned that consensual relationships which turn sour should not be turned into criminal cases. It held that a promise counts as false only when it was made in bad faith at the very start, and quashed the FIR.
How an accused can respond to a false-promise-of-marriage FIR
Seek anticipatory bail
If arrest is feared after an FIR under Section 69 BNS (or old Section 376 IPC), an application can be made to the Sessions Court or High Court under Section 482 BNSS. Courts look at how long the relationship lasted, the delay in the FIR and the documents on record. See anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS.
Collect the record of the relationship
Keep messages, photographs, travel records, any affidavits or stamp papers, and details of meetings between the families. These help show a long, voluntary relationship. In Rana, the voluntary trips, the family marriage talks and the two-year delay all weighed with the Supreme Court.
Apply for discharge before charges are framed
Once the case reaches the Sessions Court, the accused can ask to be discharged under Section 250 BNSS (formerly Section 227 CrPC). The ground is that the police report and documents do not give sufficient grounds to proceed. The judge forms a prima facie view on the material on record.
Challenge the charge order or move for quashing
If discharge is refused, the order can be challenged in revision under Section 438 BNSS (formerly Section 397 CrPC). A petition can also be filed in the High Court under Section 528 BNSS (formerly Section 482 CrPC) to quash the FIR or the proceedings as an abuse of process. Read quashing of criminal cases in the Calcutta High Court.
Approach the Supreme Court
If the High Court refuses relief, a Special Leave Petition can be filed under Article 136 of the Constitution. In Rana, the Supreme Court granted leave, stayed the trial, and then quashed the orders of both the Sessions Judge and the High Court. You can discuss your matter with a Kolkata criminal lawyer.
Points the Supreme Court weighed in the Rana case
A checklist of the facts that led to the quashing of the proceedings.
The parties were in a relationship for almost two years before the FIR.
The FIR was lodged in September 2018 for events alleged in 2016.
The complainant went with the appellant to Gwalior and a temple, and raised no alarm.
No photographs, mobile phone or jewellery were seized by the police.
Her statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC contained contradictions.
Both families knew of the relationship and discussed marriage.
Mistakes that weaken a defence in promise-to-marry cases
Treating every broken promise as a crime, or as no crime at all The courts ask whether the promise was false when it was made, not merely whether the marriage happened. Both sides should look at intent at the start, as Pramod Suryabhan Pawar and Naim Ahamed require.
Deleting chats, photographs or travel records The record of a long, voluntary relationship is often the strongest material for anticipatory bail, discharge or quashing. Keep it safe and unaltered.
Waiting until trial to raise the defence A discharge application and a quashing petition are filed at the early stages. Missing them can mean a long trial even where, as in Rana, the material is weak.
Citing the wrong law for the date of the offence Acts done before 1 July 2024 are tried under the IPC and CrPC. Later acts fall under Section 69 BNS and the BNSS. Check which law applies before drafting. See IPC to BNS.
Facing or defending a false promise of marriage case?
Whether an FIR under Section 376 IPC or Section 69 BNS can be quashed depends on the exact material: the timeline, the messages, the statements and the evidence collected. Our Kolkata criminal lawyer team can look at your papers, explain the remedies in the High Court and the Supreme Court, and advise on bail and quashing. This page is general information and not advice on any particular case; no result can be promised.
Book a ConsultationEstablished by a distinguished alumnus of IIT Kharagpur, Patra’s Law Chambers stands as a beacon of legal expertise in Kolkata & Delhi. Know more →
Kolkata Office
NICCO House, 6th Floor, 2 Hare Street
Kolkata-700001 (Near Calcutta High Court)
Delhi Office
4455/5, First Floor, Gali Shahid Bhagat Singh
Main Bazar Road, Paharganj, New Delhi-110055
Contact
[email protected]
+91 890 222 4444 / +91 7003 715 325
Maximum imprisonment for the offences in this area
The maximum jail terms under the main BNS provisions linked to this case.
Frequently asked questions on false promise of marriage and Section 376 IPC / Section 69 BNS
Following Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 9 SCC 608, the promise must be false and made in bad faith, and it must be of immediate relevance to the woman’s decision to engage in the act. A later breach alone is not enough.
Yes, in a fit case. In Shiv Pratap Singh Rana v. State of Madhya Pradesh, the Supreme Court quashed the proceedings because the relationship appeared consensual, the FIR came two years late, and nothing corroborated the allegations. Each case turns on its own facts.
Section 69 BNS now deals separately with sexual intercourse by deceitful means, including a false promise of marriage, with imprisonment up to ten years and fine. Rape itself is punished under Section 64 BNS. Please verify the text of the sections before relying on them.
It dealt with rape committed repeatedly on the same woman. The charge against Shiv Pratap Singh Rana was framed under this section and Section 506 IPC. The corresponding punishment provision under the BNS is Section 64.
The FIR was lodged about two years after the alleged events, and the parties had been in a relationship during that time. The Court treated this, with other facts, as pointing to a consensual relationship that had soured.
No. Delay in sexual offence cases is judged on its explanation. A delay is only one factor, and courts also look at the complainant’s conduct, statements and any supporting material.
Yes. A revision lies against the charge-framing order under Section 438 BNSS (earlier Section 397 CrPC), and quashing can be sought under Section 528 BNSS (earlier Section 482 CrPC) where the case is an abuse of process. A lawyer should assess the facts first.
Yes, as early as possible. The choice between bail, discharge, revision and quashing depends on the stage and the papers. You can read about our criminal law practice in Kolkata and see the code conversion table at IPC to BNS.