• Creditor and contributor of this article:

  Patra’s Law Chambers:

  About Us:

  Patra’s Law Chambers is a law firm with offices in Kolkata &  Delhi, offering comprehensive legal services across various domains. Established in 2020 by Advocate Sudip Patra (Advocate, Supreme Court of India & Calcutta High Court) an alumnus of the Prestigious Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, IIT Kharagpur ,with Post Graduate diploma in Business Law from IIM Calcutta, the firm specializes in Civil, Criminal, Writs,High Court Matters, Trademark, Copyright, Company, Tax, Banking, Property disputes, Service law, Family law, and Supreme Court matters.You can know more about us in here

  Kolkata Office:

  NICCO HOUSE, 6th Floor, 2, Hare Street, Kolkata-700001 (Near Calcutta High Court)

  Delhi Office:

  House no: 4455/5, First Floor, Ward No. XV, Gali Shahid

  Bhagat Singh, Main Bazar Road, Paharganj, New Delhi-110055

  Website: www.patraslawchambers.com

  Email: admin@patraslawchambers.com

  Phone: +91 890 222 4444/ +91 7003 715 325

1. Introduction: The Evolution from CrPC to BNSS

The Indian criminal justice system is undergoing a foundational shift with the introduction of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, which is set to replace the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973. A critical area of this legislative evolution concerns the police’s power to arrest and the procedural safeguards protecting individual liberty.

A cornerstone of these safeguards under the CrPC is Section 41A, which mandates a “Notice of appearance” in lieu of arrest for specific offenses. The user’s query regarding Section 35 and its correlation with Section 41A strikes at the heart of this change.

To clarify:

• Section 41 of CrPC outlines when police may arrest without a warrant.
• Section 41A of CrPC acts as a limitation on that power, mandating a notice for offenses punishable with 7 years or less.
• Section 35 of BNSS, 2023, is the new provision corresponding to Section 41 of CrPC.
• The principle of Section 41A (CrPC) has been directly incorporated into Section 35(3) of the BNSS.

This analysis provides a deep dive into the correlation between these provisions, the jurisprudence that shaped them, their practical applicability, and the landmark judgments that govern this field.

2. The Legislative Framework: CrPC vs. BNSS

The primary change is not one of spirit but of structure. The BNSS streamlines the provisions, making the limitation on arrest (the 41A notice) an integral part of the section on arrest powers, rather than a separate section.

Key Correlation & Change:

The BNSS takes the mandate of Section 41A (CrPC) and makes it a subsection

$$Sec 35(3)$$

of the primary power to arrest (Sec 35). This structural change emphasizes that the notice is the default rule, and arrest is the exception that must be justified. The “Section 35 Notice” under BNSS is the new “41A Notice.”

3. The Law and Jurisprudence: Why the Notice Exists

The provision for a notice of appearance was introduced via the CrPC (Amendment) Act, 2008 (effective 2010). The legislative intent, bolstered by judicial pronouncements, was to address several key issues:

1. Overcrowded Jails: A significant portion of the jail population comprised undertrial prisoners, many arrested for minor offenses where pre-trial arrest was unnecessary.
2. Protection of Liberty: To uphold the fundamental right to liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution, ensuring that arrest—a draconian measure—is not used mechanically.
3. Preventing Harassment: To stop the police from using the power of arrest as a tool for harassment or extortion, especially in cases like matrimonial disputes (498A), minor scuffles, or cheating.

The jurisprudence was famously cemented by the Supreme Court in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar** (2014)**. This judgment transformed Section 41A from a procedural guideline into a mandatory directive.

The Mandate of Arnesh Kumar (Governing both 41A CrPC & 35 BNSS):

The Supreme Court, observing rampant misuse of arrest powers, laid down binding directions:

1. Mandatory Notice: For any offense punishable with imprisonment of 7 years or less (with or without a fine), the police must issue a notice of appearance (under Sec 41A CrPC / Sec 35(3) BNSS) to the accused.
2. No Automatic Arrest: The accused shall not be arrested if they comply with the notice and continue to appear as required.
3. Justification for Arrest: A police officer can only arrest if they have “reason to believe” that such arrest is necessary for specific, recorded reasons (the “Section 41(1)(b)(ii) checklist” in CrPC, now in Sec 35(1) BNSS):

• To prevent the accused from committing any further offense.
• For proper investigation of the offense.
• To prevent the accused from tampering with evidence.
• To prevent the accused from threatening or inducing any witness.
• To ensure the accused’s presence in court when required.

1. Written Reasons: The officer must record these reasons in writing. If they decide not to arrest, that reason must also be recorded.
2. Judicial Scrutiny: The Magistrate, when authorizing detention, must scrutinize the police report and be satisfied that the arrest is justified based on these recorded reasons.
3. Consequences of Non-Compliance (by Police): Failure to comply with these directions would make the police officer liable for departmental action and contempt of court.

4. Applicability: 20 Common Scenarios for a Notice (Section 35 BNSS / 41A CrPC)

A notice under Section 35(3) BNSS (formerly 41A CrPC) is the standard procedure in all cases where the maximum punishment is imprisonment for 7 years or less. This applies to a vast number of FIRs.

Here are 20 common offenses

$$with corresponding old IPC and new BNS (Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita) sections$$

where such a notice is mandatory:

1. Cruelty by Husband/Relatives (Sec 498A IPC / Sec 84 BNS): The Arnesh Kumar case itself arose from this, making it the classic example. (Punishment: 3 years).
2. Theft (Sec 379 IPC / Sec 301 BNS): Simple theft. (Punishment: 3 years).
3. Cheating (Sec 420 IPC / Sec 316 BNS): Many white-collar and financial disputes. (Punishment: 7 years).
4.  ): (Punishment: 3 years).
5. Rash and Negligent Driving (Sec 279 IPC / Sec 106(1) BNS): Common in accident cases. (Punishment: 6 months).
6. Causing Death by Negligence (Sec 304A IPC / Sec 106(2) BNS): (Punishment: 2 years, though note BNS has a separate provision for “hit and run”).
7. Simple Hurt (Sec 323 IPC / Sec 113 BNS): (Punishment: 1 year).
8. Grievous Hurt (Sec 325 IPC / Sec 114 BNS): (Punishment: 7 years).
9. Wrongful Restraint (Sec 341 IPC / Sec 136 BNS): (Punishment: 1 month).
10. Assault on a Woman to Outrage Modesty (Sec 354 IPC / Sec 73 BNS): (Punishment: 1-5 years).
11. Stalking (Sec 354D IPC / Sec 77 BNS): (Punishment: 3-5 years).
12. Defamation (Sec 499/500 IPC / Sec 354 BNS): (Punishment: 2 years).
13. Criminal Intimidation (Sec 506 IPC / Sec 350 BNS): (Punishment: 2 years, or 7 if threat is severe).
14. Insult to Modesty of a Woman (Sec 509 IPC / Sec 78 BNS): (Punishment: 3 years).
15. Mischief (Sec 427 IPC / Sec 322 BNS): Causing damage to property. (Punishment: 2 years).
16. House Trespass (Sec 448 IPC / Sec 328 BNS): (Punishment: 1 year).
17. Rioting (Sec 147 IPC / Sec 187 BNS): (Punishment: 2 years).
18. Affray (Sec 160 IPC / Sec 190 BNS): (Punishment: 1 month).
19. Negligent Conduct with Fire (Sec 285 IPC): (Punishment: 6 months).
20. Adulteration of Food/Drink (Sec 272 IPC): (Punishment: 6 months).

In all these scenarios, filing an FIR does not automatically give police the power to arrest. They must first issue a Section 35(3) BNSS notice.

5. Landmark Judgments on Section 41A CrPC (Applicable to Sec 35 BNSS)

The following table outlines the key judgments that have shaped the law on arrest and the necessity of a 41A notice.

6. Conclusion

The transition from Section 41A of the CrPC to Section 35(3) of the BNSS is a positive legislative reinforcement of judicial wisdom. By embedding the “notice of appearance” directly into the section governing the power to arrest, the law now more clearly and forcefully communicates that arrest is the last resort, not the first step.

For any person named in an FIR for an offense punishable with 7 years or less, the “Section 35 Notice” is a legal right. Compliance with this notice is the surest way to avoid pre-trial detention, and non-compliance by the police is a serious procedural lapse that can be grounds for bail, departmental action, and even contempt of court. This provision is a critical safeguard for the liberty of the common citizen against the arbitrary exercise of state power.

Disclaimer: This write-up is for informational and academic purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal issues, please consult with a qualified legal professional.

A Research Publication by:

Patra’s Law Chambers

Kolkata Office:

NICCO HOUSE, 6th Floor, 2, Hare Street, Kolkata-700001 (Near Calcutta High Court)

Delhi Office:

House no: 4455/5, First FSection 35 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhitaloor, Ward No. XV, Gali Shahid Bhagat Singh, Main Bazar Road, Paharganj, New Delhi-110055

Website: www.patraslawchambers.com

Email: admin@patraslawchambers.com

Section 35 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita_watermarkPhone: +91 890 222 4444 / +91 9044 04 9044

RESOURCES: DOWNLOAD THIS ARTICLE AS PDF

The post Complete guide to police notice under Section 35 BNSS / Section 41A CrPC first appeared on Patras Law Chamber.